Back to Mustang Football History home page
| Year | Player | Position | Conference |
| 2010 | Aubrey Coleman | WR | Southeast |
| 2005 | Sean Sheller | OL | Division VII |
| 2004 | Kyle Necke | LB | Division VII |
| Tommy Liu | OL | Division VII | |
| Conrad White | DB | Division VII | |
| 2003 | Michael Campos | DL | Division VII |
| 2002 | Daniel Al-Gattas | Offensive MVP | Division VII |
| Ryan O’Shields | RB | Division VII | |
| Da Mon Lindsey | WR | Division VII | |
| Moses Hurtado | LB | Division VII | |
| James GoIlaz | DL | Division VII | |
| Henri Pamphile | DB | Division VII | |
| 2001 | Daniel Al-Gattas | P | Division II |
| 1996 | Jon Al-Gattas | P | Division VI |
| 1995 | Eddie Diaz | LB | Division VI |
| 1994 | Jamie Sykes | OL | Division VI |
| 1992 | Tommy Vazquez | B | Division VI |
| 1991 | Jason Hill | OL | Division IV |
| 1990 | James Robinson | DL | Division IV |
| 1988 | Carnell Carter | OL | Division IV |
| 1977 | Steve Green | QB | Northeastern Conf. |
| Mike Porter | DL | Northeastern Conf. | |
| 1976 | Kevin Morgan | RB | Northeastern Conf. |
| 1975 | Don Reed | LB | Division 2A |
| Kevin Veselic | LB | Division 2A | |
| Steve Walsh | OL | Division 2A | |
| 1974 | Rick Packer | OL | Division 2A |
| 1973 | Lance Parrish | QB | Division 2A |
| 1972 | Ron Himes | QB | Division 2A |
| Lance Parrish | DB | Division 2A | |
| 1971 | Ron Himes | QB | Division 2A |
| John McIntyre | WR | Division 2A | |
| 1970 | Bruce Cheek | LB | Division 2A |
